Thomas Mann’s Reception in Japan between Cultural Heteronomy and Emancipatory Impulses
October 2023 - ongoing
Renowned German literature critic Marcel Reich-Ranicki referred to Thomas Mann’s Tonio Kröger as the "novel of the century" (Jahrhunderterzählung). This rings true not only for the European and American audiences he had in mind, but especially for 20th-century Japan. Immediately after the first Japanese translation was released by the prestigious publishing company Iwanami Shoten in 1927, it became a seminal text for Japan’s academic kyōyōshugi (the ideology of German “Bildung” or intellectual self-cultivation) elite, who projected their own struggle with hastily imported Western culture onto Tonio’s ideological dilemma between artistic sensibilities and societal norms.
While this first translation remained highly influential for Japanese intellectuals until recently, it was followed by 15 retranslations. Each of these retranslations tells a rich story about the historical context from which it emerged: Saneyoshi Hayao’s first translation, praised by kyōyōshugi academics for its exceedingly "faithful," foreignizing reproduction of Mann’s stylistics and even syntax, was followed by retranslations that were censored for political reasons, by others that hugely benefitted from the post-war “world literature” boom, and by more recent attempts to rewrite Tonio’s 19th-century story for a modern-day Japanese audience. This timeline allows us to retrace not only shifting Japanese attitudes toward Mann and kyōyōshugi, but also gradual changes in Japanese translation culture and in Japan’s cultural self-image toward the West.
These changes are explored and contextualized through a digitally augmented, topic modeling-based full-text analysis of the 15 Japanese Tonio Kröger retranslations. The approach does not primarily focus on each retranslation’s degree of "faithfulness" to the source text, but rather on the relationships among the different retranslations. The predominantly stylometric analysis of those relationships sheds light on the hidden mechanisms that have shaped Japan’s scholarly translation culture in the context of kyōyōshugi – that is, on patterns of similarity and influence between different retranslations, which can be traced back to various types of relationships (such as colleague, rival, or mentor) among the translators.
Nicole Marion Mueller